Sunday, December 24, 2017

[Manga Review] Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas by Jun Asuka

Manga Review of Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas by Jun Asuka

Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas by Jun Asuka is a manga filled with lovely artwork!

I'm a huge Nightmare fan so I couldn't wait to give this one a read during the holidays! Unfortunately, I didn't really care for the organization of the dialogue and how it guided the story along.

Let's dive in.

Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas by Jun Asuka

Synopsis:
Jack Skellington is the Pumpkin King, the ruler of Halloween Town and master of all things creepy and spooky. But he's tired of his life in the shadows and longs for something new. When he accidentally stumbles upon Christmas Town, he decides this is the perfect chance to try his hand at a brand new holiday and is convinced he'll have the world yelling "Scary Christmas"! With the young patchwork doll Sally trying to dissuade him and the evil Oogie Boogie waiting in the wings to take over Halloween Town in Jack's absence, he'd better hurry if he wants to get his plan in place by December 25th! You've seen the movie, now read the manga for a new twist on an animated classic!


My thoughts:
The artwork was definitely my favorite element of this manga. The texture and detail was so lovely!


The style around some of the text boxes was also great!


I really enjoyed that the actions were sometimes included in the illustration. Example: 


My favorite scene from this manga was:


This panel comparison between the two towns was a nice touch:



Beware, the negatives:
Because this manga is rather short, I was worried that a lot of the plot would be left out, but it wasn’t too bad! The storyline captured the main arc of the plot in a decent manner. Though I do think I would have been pretty confused if I didn't already know the story so well.

I really liked that the nod to the songs from the film were set in fancy font.


However, the transitions between the “song” bits and the normal dialogue in the panels were very abrupt. As a reader that knows all the songs, that kept throwing me for a loop. But if you can stop trying to finish the song, it will flow a little better. However, that being said, the story overall still seemed very choppy to me. More than a couple times I had to go back a panel or two to see if I had missed something...

There was also this error... The "Sandy" should be "Sally."



My final thoughts:
Overall, this was a fun read, but I was just very underwhelmed with it. The artwork was great but the choppiness of the storyline and dialogue really dragged it down...


Thanks for reading!
What is your favorite manga?
SaveSave

10 comments:

  1. I hate that this didn't work for you! It's always so upsetting when something we love doesn't meet our expectations. However, I do love this movie! I will watch it randomly throughout the year, but I don't think this is something I will pick up to read. Thanks for sharing this!

    Do You Dog-ear?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm the same way with the movie! I watch it many times throughout the year. It's just SO good!

      Delete
  2. I do love the artwork but it sounds like the storyline wouldn't capture me...

    Have a nice Christmas!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, it was quite rough... Thanks for stopping by! Merry (belated) Christmas to you! :)

      Delete
  3. I've never read a manga before but I do agree I think the artwork would be the best thing about this one.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've only read a handful. I really enjoy the format, though it does take a few pages to get used to the flow... but this one just didn't work at all :(

      Delete
  4. I've only seen the movie and thought it was quite entertaining. It's rare, but I wonder if this is a unique case when the movie is better than the book? Hmmm...

    Lonna @ FLYLÄ“F

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. For sure! The children's book version is lovely though! :)

      Delete
  5. I can't believe another Christmas has gone by and I still haven't seen this movie! I actually might read the manga instead though - the artwork looks so adorable!

    ReplyDelete